Random Blog Infinite Connections: Reality Dating TV: A Sociological Experiment?

Tuesday, July 08, 2008

Reality Dating TV: A Sociological Experiment?

I'm glad to hear I'm not the only one with an embarrassing interest in reality TV. (Thanks Washwords!) I won't even try to justify it. It is what it is.

This is the first season of the Bachelor/Bachelorette series that I've watched in a long time. Not sure why I got into this time except that it has corresponded with the times that I need some background noise for some work I'm doing. (There- I justified myself anyway!)

What interests me about this franchise is some of the things it seems to suggest about the genders and their pursuit for love. A few things I've noticed over the years:

* When a Bachelor chooses a woman after "dating" 24 other women, he rarely stays with her very long after the show. (Or in the case of Brad Womack, he decides he's done with all of them by the last episode.)

*When a woman is doing the choosing amongst 25 men, the relationship more often results in an engagement, long term relationship and/or marriage.

What conclusions could we possibly draw from this? That once men have a taste for multiple women, it's a hard habit to break? That whenever men are knowingly competing for the attentions of one woman, they tend to "fall" harder?

Ick. Hope not.

Yet as I watched this season, it was hard not to think that was the case. The men get to spend very little one on one time with the Bachelorette, and not only do they know she's dating others, they know exactly who, what, when and where it's happening!

Deanna, an attractive, nice-enough girl, actually had four men fall pretty deeply in love with her during the course of this show. Which takes place over a matter of weeks. Weeks. Deeply in love. Declaring their love on national TV. Crying over the prospect of losing her.

Three of the men wanted to marry her. Were practically begging to marry her.

So which one(s) did she fall for?

Hmmmm...first it was the super hot, sexy Graham who was emotionally distant and had trouble with commitment. Somehow, Deanna got up the courage to cut him loose, but everyone could see she was WAY into him.

Of course, Jeremy never stood a chance. He was declaring his feelings for her from the get-go. He was uber-attentive, extra romantic, very vulnerable. Supposedly everything Deanna wanted on paper, yet "something" was missing.

Poor single-dad Jason actually went as far as getting on his knee to propose, before Deanna said "wait! I can't!" The words she used to describe him? "A great father, stable, comfortable, loving, safe."

So she goes with Jesse, the wild snow boarder, who had no intentions of getting married when he started the show. But after getting caught up in the pursuit, the competition, or whatever it is, he walks away engaged to his "soul mate".

I thought love was a magical, chemical, indescribable thing that happens only rarely and in the right conditions? Because it seems to me that in this case, the love was manufactured and generated by the circumstances. Master manipulation. Tell me, does that mean the love wasn't real?

10 Comments:

At 9:15 PM, Blogger Kristin said...

I don't know, but you make me want to watch the show. I've been leery of watching love that blossoms in such an environment.

 
At 9:39 PM, Blogger Hammer said...

This is precisely why America is doomed. When the Apocalypse finally comes, everyone will just think it's a reality TV show.

Not me though, I'll be down in my survival bunker eating SPAM and playing Spades with my imaginary friends.

You have all been warned.

 
At 2:43 AM, Blogger Aileen said...

Kristin- I know! It sucks you in...I swear!

Ham- As long as it's not cribbage. That would be truly depressing for you.

 
At 2:50 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

infinite aileen... uhh thanks for the shout out? or should i say outting me further! lol.

I agree. it DOES suck you in. I could argue that I'm just watching to be postmodern, do some sort of feminist critique but... it wouldn't be true. There are at least a dozen social psych, media, women's studies theses in here though really.

I just still feel sad for poor Jason. Really, deeply, sad.

Another sadness: I got more hits today than I have for a while. ah well, least my poppiness is paying off, kinda?

 
At 12:23 PM, Blogger Ryane said...

Personally, I think those shows are all phony. I haven't ever really watched the Bachelor or the Bachelorette, but I know enough from the premise to know that that kind of love...the chances of it being real (at least to me)...are slim to none. I just can't get around the fact that it's TV, you know? It's not supposed to be real!! Anyway...sorry. Good post!

 
At 1:48 PM, Blogger Aileen said...

washwords- I agree about all the social psych studies in there...And I wouldn't worry about Jason. I thought he pretty much out-classed Deanna anyway. And he's a great guy, so he'll have no trouble finding love again!

ryane- Yup. It's tv. But people are falling in love online, too, and some of that isn't phony. And I've even heard that some people date through *gasp* blogging. So who's to say? But even though it's contrived and phony, the outcome was that a couple people had their hearts broken (for real) and a couple is engaged to be married next spring- for a real life marriage. It's all very surreal!

 
At 8:02 PM, Blogger Gary said...

Oh, this post was a riot up until that last sentence/question which left me all confused and befuddled. Hold me! Make it all go away!

Boy, lots of drama on reality TV huh? The only show I kinda got into was the first few seasons of The Apprentice. I feel like I am missing something here.

 
At 12:37 AM, Blogger Ulysses said...

The love is as real as the rest of it.
My interest in reality TV waned early, during Survivor, where the members of the team are all manuevering to get one up on their teammates so that they can stab them in the back when the time comes. That's nothing like my reality.

 
At 3:04 PM, Blogger bulletholes said...

I've never seen one of these shows, but on the odd accaasion qwhen I am kliving right, this is my creed:
" We seek in others that which is the deepest reflection of ourselves and to the extent with which we value that reflection we will either EXPERIENCE, or FAKE, a sense of self -esteem."

i can't help but think that that which is contrived or manufactured wcould be anytrhing but partially faked, at least in the short term compression of these shows, or the dating habits of their counterparts.

 
At 7:47 PM, Blogger Aileen said...

gary- glad I could amuse you! Yeah, I get kinda skeptical, but then I'm also a romantic...I want to know it's possible to find love anywhere and everywhere!

ulysses- yeah I haven't watched survivor in years! But I have a feeling my guilty pleasure for reality tv will go on for awhile...

steve- yeah the consensus here is of course a general sense of skepticism about the true reality of such shows. But I still have to wonder!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

Directory of Personal Blogs Web Site Counter
Free Counter Subscribe with Bloglines